- Internal DAC chip: TI/BB PCM1748E
Setup: i7 computer system with the analogue outputs of SB3 --> E-MU 0404USB. Details for this setup is same as Essence One tests.
Here's the oscilloscope plot of a 1kHz square wave at 0dBFS off the analogue outputs. Square wave have a slight downward slant. Peak voltage 2.64V. Nice channel balance (yellow = right, blue = left).
Standard linear phase digital reconstruction filter.
RESULTS:
First 2 columns are the stock SB3+stock wallwart connected to my basement music server by WiFi. Notice that 24-bit data does result in dropping of the noise floor by ~6dB. It looks like the good ol' SB3 internal DAC is capable of about 17-bit resolution when fed with 24-bits. Note that the old Stereophile review from 2006 did not measure 24-bit performance.
Second 2 columns are the same setup but with the ethernet (hooked up to my DLink gigabit switch 6 feet away). Essentially no difference compared to the WiFi.
Final column is with the SB3 over WiFi but the *SB Touch wallwart*. I see folks here talking about the crappy wallwart (true, the UNIFIVE wallwart looks and feels nasty compared to the one that came with the Touch!). I fed the 24-bit data and the result is essentially the same as the UNIFIVE. Based on these measurements, I don't see any evidence that the Touch wallwart would improve the stock SB3 performace.
Frequency Response:
Decent - obviously not as flat as Essence One from 20Hz-20kHz...
Noise Floor:
16-bit data obviously not as good as 24-bits. No difference between the WiFi vs. Ethernet groups.
THD Graph:
Dunn J-Test:
16-bit (16/44) -
CONCLUSION:
1. The SB3 can benefit from 24-bit "hi-res" audio. Whether you can hear the extra 5-6dB is your problem :-)
2. I see no evidence that a Touch wallwart would improve the performance over the cheap stock power supply. Who know is the multi-hundred $$$ or linear power supplies make a difference...
3. No evidence that running in WiFi mode will add any noise to the SB3 output.
4. The Dunn J-Test is demonstrating minimal jitter.
Squeezebox 3 has production flaw, electrolytic capacitors between DAC and OpAmp are turned wrong way. As they are inversly polarized, they deteriorate with time, causing noticable degradation of audio quality.
ReplyDeleteI had no idea that the SB3 could play 24 bit files. Also, I had no idea that the D/A converter in the SB3 was this good. Thanks for posting this!
ReplyDelete