The Dolby Atmos Music Target Curve. And on being an audiophile "tonmeister".

[For the post this week, let's take a pause from the Pacific Audio Fest 2024 discussions (last 2 weeks). Next week we'll have a Part III discussion about audio shows.]

Standardization is generally good.

I've discussed in previous posts that Dolby Atmos defines loudness characteristics for recordings and this has helped preserve dynamic range in multichannel/Atmos albums following their guidelines. Likewise, we can benefit from standardization of the frequency response as this will allow us to better "translate" the sound from the studio into our sound rooms. This idea is not new for audiophiles. The ill-fated (with good reason) MQA promised that we could experience the "sound of the studio", but they never could deliver in a large part because there was never any standardization for essential parameters like the frequency response, among other failings. In the same way, back in the day (~2014), this was the promise of hi-res audio by Neil Young and Pono that you would somehow get the "finest digital copy" and this would represent the sound the artists intended from the studio; clearly they overpromised and under-delivered by 2015.

It's one thing to standardize between the studio and home ("inter-system") playback, but it's also important to standardize "intra-system" - that is, between all the speakers in your set-up when you're doing multichannel such that each speaker is calibrated to the same timbre. This is important in a multichannel layout since we do not want "objects" moving through space changing tonality because of mismatch between speakers around the listener. The Dolby Atmos Music Target Curve is Dolby's recommendation for the music studio frequency response. This curve evolved from the X-Curve, an 'X'perimental frequency response based on some early empirical work exploring the performance of actual theater sound systems starting in the 1970's, and evolved over the years. See this paper for more details, note some similarity of the Dolby Atmos Music Target Curve to the SMPTE 202M - 1998 X-Curve.

As with all things in audio, nothing wrong with asking whether this curve is the "best". 🤔

Pacific Audio Fest 2024: Part II. [About that MACHINA DYNAMICA, and mental health. 🫣]

PAF'24 - the balcony shot on a Sunday afternoon as things start to wrap up...

So let's continue with the September 6-8, 2024 Pacific Audio Fest show-and-tell (Part I last week) at Seattle. These are my visits to the rooms on Sunday September 8th. You've probably seen from my previous show reports that Sundays tend to be less busy than Fridays and Saturdays. Often this is not a bad day to visit because it means that the crowds are smaller, you'll be able to linger a bit longer to enjoy the music, are more likely to be able to request music, and the reps are easier to access if you have questions (or concerns). It's also a good day to make deals since many rooms would rather sell you the gear than pack stuff up and take home that evening. I know some folks scored some barely used room treatments.

Let's spend some time on Wing 2 of the main floor, and then the larger 2nd Floor "Cascades" rooms to finish off. As with last week, all prices are in US dollars unless specified otherwise.

Pacific Audio Fest 2024: Part I. [And expensive speaker cables unanimously turned down in a blind test?! 😕]

This is the third year for the Pacific Audio Fest which first started in 2022, basically after the COVID-19 pandemic reopenings. I think the first 2 years of the show were quite similar in size but this third show is clearly a smaller event with fewer display rooms and less stalls in the Marketplace. Correlated with that, I also noticed fewer headphone set-ups to try out.

To be honest, while I think this probably was disappointing for some, I only had a couple of days to visit anyways so this actually worked out driving into Seattle on Saturday morning, stayed a night, and got home by later afternoon Sunday having felt like I spent enough time in each room, even visiting a few of the rooms a number of times to compare.

So, let's have a peek at some audiophile eye-candy and consider the goods out on display this year. Let's be honest, one of the most important specs whenever doing any shopping is the asking price. Unless specified otherwise, all prices are in USD.

The show ran from September 6-8, 2024 at the SeaTac DoubleTree Hilton which is the same as in previous years. I spent the 7th and 8th "hitting the rooms". Let's go!

AS WE HEAR IT: Moving forward as audiophiles & a plea for higher dynamic range music (to Epica). [Plus highest DR Oasis - Definitely Maybe.]

Well, this weekend is Pacific Audio Fest 2024 and I figure since it's nearby in Seattle and they've decided to make it every 2 years (next in 2026), I'll pop down for a look and listen for a couple days. It's fun staying incognito for the most part as a "more objective" audiophile even if this might not be the prevailing culture at these shows to get a sense of how the megabuck systems perform, what's potentially exciting, and observe the trajectory of the hobby. Given the busyness of work these days, I'll just take my time this year on the show reports with pictures, sharing some thoughts over the next couple weeks.

For this post, it's time for an "As We Hear It" article based on reader E-mails.

I. First Watt Amplifiers & Progressing as Audiophiles

June 26, 2024

Hi Achi:

Your blog took me here (ie. E-mail address) and thanks for all your wonderful work to make the audiophiles' world a better place. Here is my little story.

I have been an audiophile for as long as I can remember. But only recently decided to get serious about the equipment side of things. Thanks to the YouTube channel called Audiophiliac by Steve Guttenberg, I quickly decided to get a pair of Magnepan speakers. That was wonderful, due to planar construction, the transparency and soundstage is amazing.